Relative Value13balanced preset
Crucial BX500 1TB vs Western Digital Green 1TB — value comparison
See current offers for Crucial BX500 1TB
Relative Value14balanced preset
Crucial BX500 1TB and Western Digital Green 1TB are practically even under balanced weights at the current dataset offers: 13 vs 14. Change the preset or your priorities before deciding.
Price data · United States · USD · New · A 2026-09-16 · B 2026-09-16Coverage · 3 tracked new-offer records across both modelsBenchmark confidence · no estimate flags on these two recordsAffiliate links · We may earn a commission from these links. Scores are calculated separately using our methodology.
02 · Decision matrix
One decision, three separate questions
Capability ignores price. Relative Value adds the current dataset offers and your priorities. Keeping them separate prevents a cheap product from being mistaken for the faster product.
The decision, split by questioncapability · value · price are separate answers
Capability by task
| Scenario | Crucial BX500 1TB | Western Digital Green 1TB |
|---|---|---|
| System Drive | A#219 | A#218 |
| Game & File Storage | B#194 | B#277 |
| Heavy Creative Work | D#343 | C#337✓ |
Western Digital Green 1TB grades higher in 1 of 3 graded scenarios (2 tied) and is never graded lower. These are the same S–F grades as the tier list — capability only, price excluded. The value rows below add prices from the 2026-09-16 offer frame. How tiers are assigned →
Relative Value by priority
Balancedpractically even (≤3 pts)
13
14
System Drivepractically even (≤3 pts)
0
0
Game & File Storagepractically even (≤3 pts)
39
40
Heavy Creative Workpractically even (≤3 pts)
0
0
Strict Budgetpractically even (≤3 pts)
38
39
Both products are normalized within the same in-stock market frame per preset. A check marks the higher Relative Value; a difference of 3 points or less is shown as practically even.
03 · Price crossover
The price changes the answer
Current offers, crossover points and Strong Value thresholds answer different questions. Thresholds are calculations, not price forecasts.
A · Crucial BX500 1TB
- Current dataset offer · NewUnited States · USD · snapshot 2026-09-16
- $180
- Beats Western Digital Green 1TB atbalanced weights; rival offer held fixed
- $170
- Strong Value at80+ Relative Value threshold
- $14
B · Western Digital Green 1TB
- Current dataset offer · NewUnited States · USD · snapshot 2026-09-16
- $180
- Beats Crucial BX500 1TB atbalanced weights; rival offer held fixed
- $191
- Strong Value at80+ Relative Value threshold
- $15
04 · Where to buy
Current offers for both products
Dated New-condition price snapshots for only the two products in this comparison. Confirm the final price and availability at the store.
A · Crucial BX500 1TB
New · United States · USDAmazon Affiliate
Check on AmazonB · Western Digital Green 1TB
New · United States · USDAmazon Affiliate
Check on Amazon05 · Capability
Capability indexes, side by side
Price is intentionally excluded here so the more capable product and the better-value product cannot be confused.
Drive capability
540
545
545
Sequential read (MB/s)
540
545
545
Sequential write (MB/s)
500
430
430
A · Crucial BX500 1TBB · Western Digital Green 1TBEach row keeps the unit or category index named in its label; bar length compares A and B within that row.The Value leader depends on how you weight things: Crucial BX500 1TB leads under 0 presets, Western Digital Green 1TB under 0, 5 practically even.
06 · Platform & ownership
Fit, compatibility and ownership context
Only verified structured compatibility and ownership fields are shown. Check the exact system, board manual and vendor QVL before purchase; missing fields are never guessed.
A · Crucial BX500 1TB
- InterfaceSATA 6.0 Gb/s
- Form factor2.5"
- Capacity1,000 GB
- DRAM cacheDRAM-less
- Heatsink includedNo
- Write endurance360 TBW
- Warranty (typical new)60 mo
B · Western Digital Green 1TB
- InterfaceSATA 6.0 Gb/s
- Form factor2.5"
- Capacity1,000 GB
- DRAM cacheDRAM-less
- Heatsink includedNo
- Write endurance600 TBW
- Warranty (typical new)60 mo
07 · Specifications
Key specifications
Directional checkmarks appear only on numeric fields where more or less has a clear meaning. They are not an overall verdict.
| Specification | Crucial BX500 1TB | Western Digital Green 1TB |
|---|---|---|
| Interface | SATA 6.0 Gb/s | SATA 6.0 Gb/s |
| Form factor | 2.5" | 2.5" |
| Capacity | 1,000 GB | 1,000 GB |
| Sequential read | 540 MB/s | 545 MB/s✓ |
| Sequential write | 500 MB/s✓ | 430 MB/s |
| Write endurance | 360 TBW | 600 TBW✓ |
| DRAM cache | DRAM-less | DRAM-less |
| NAND type | Micron 3D QLC/TLC | SanDisk TLC |
| Controller | SMI SM2258XT | SMI SM2258XT |
| Heatsink included | No | No |
| Current dataset offer · New | $180snapshot 2026-09-16✓ | $180snapshot 2026-09-16 |
| Warranty (typical new) | 60 mo | 60 mo |
“Not tracked” means the source data does not contain a verified value; no default or guessed specification is substituted.
08 · Customize
Try other models and your own priorities
Presets are starting points. Swap either side, then open Advanced weights only if you want to tune the formula directly.
09 · Alternative
A third option worth checking
The same scenario and market frame checks whether another currently priced model offers a cleaner trade-off.
Worth considering instead
Patriot Viper VP4300 Lite 1TB — same S-tier capability for System Drive, about $25 cheaper · Value 37.
Neither of the two above is the only answer — this one clears the same bar for less. ⇄ Compare all three
10 · Decision guide
Choose based on the trade-off you actually want
These are evidence-linked conditions, not universal buying verdicts. Feature ecosystems, software support and platform preferences remain your call.
Choose A · Crucial BX500 1TB if…
- You can find it at or below its Strong Value threshold of $14 under balanced weights.
Choose B · Western Digital Green 1TB if…
- You prioritize Heavy Creative Work — it earns the higher capability tier in those tracked scenarios.
- You can find it at or below its Strong Value threshold of $15 under balanced weights.
11 · Methodology & FAQ
Read the methodology →How to read this comparison
The formula is a linear weighted sum inside the current comparison frame. Capability, price and user priorities stay visible as separate inputs so the result can be challenged and changed.
- Which is better value right now: Crucial BX500 1TB or Western Digital Green 1TB?
- Under the balanced preset and the 2026-09-16 offer frame, they are practically even in Relative Value (13 vs 14). Change the preset or weights to reflect your own priorities; capability is a separate question, answered by the tier table.
- Which one is more capable, ignoring price?
- Western Digital Green 1TB grades higher in 1 of 3 graded scenarios (2 tied) and is never graded lower.
- Where can I compare current offers for both?
- Dated offer snapshots for both models are listed on their product pages (linked above); the interactive calculator recalculates both with your own weights and budget.
Get more from The Comparator
🧩 Embed this on your siteFree live value widgets — drop a deal monitor or comparison into your blog or article.
🔎 Price a used listingPaste any marketplace listing and score it against today's market in the calculator.
✏️ Found a data error?Tell us — we keep prices and specs honest, dated and corrected fast.
Offer frame: 2026-09-16 · dataset generated 2026-09-16 · formula ssd-value-v1.5-benefit-cost-product · Value Score is an estimate based on our current dataset, selected weights, market prices and methodology — not an official product rating or a price forecast. Target prices are calculation thresholds, not predictions. Methodology · Report a data error