The Comparator

Academy · Understand the numbers

Capability vs Value

Every product has two numbers. Grade tells you what it can do. Value tells you how good its current price is for your priorities.

Lessons · Capability vs Value

Capability: what a product can do

A grade answers one question for one job: how well can this product do it? Graphics cards are graded separately for 1080p, 1440p and 4K gaming, for ray tracing at each resolution, for local AI and for 3D rendering. Processors are graded for gaming, productivity and performance per watt. Drives are graded as a system drive, for games and files, and for heavy creative work.

Grades run from S (excellent) to F. They come from fixed rules for each job, such as measured performance, memory, endurance and features. They never look at price. A product does not get a better grade because it got cheaper, and it keeps its grade when it goes out of stock.

If a grade rests on a figure we estimated instead of measured, the product is marked est.

A Grade column with S and A badges
Where to look: the Grade column. It does not change when you move a weight.

Value: how good the current price is for you

Value brings price back in. It weighs what a product delivers against what it costs, using your priorities: how much price matters, and how much performance, memory, efficiency, warranty or freshness matter. A preset such as 1440p Sweet Spot is a starting set of priorities. You can change any of them.

Value is a number from 0 to 100 within the view you are looking at. 100 is the top of the current scale. Several products can reach it. The same product can show a different Value on two pages that compare different products.

A table with Grade, Price and Value columns
Where to look: Price and Value next to the grade. Move a weight in Customize and Value changes while the grade stays.

Why price changes Value but not the grade

If a card gets cheaper, it does exactly what it did yesterday, so its grade stays. It is a better deal now, so its Value goes up. If you raise the weight on price, cheaper products move up. The products did not change. Your priorities did.

Reading them together

You seeIt meansWhat to do
High grade, low ValueVery capable, but expensive for what you askedLook at a lower grade that still clears your job
Modest grade, high ValueA good deal, if that grade is enoughCheck the grade against your job
High grade, high ValueCapable and well priced for your prioritiesCompare it with the next one down
Low grade, low ValueNeitherSkip it

To find products that are good enough and good value, set a minimum grade for your job, then sort by Value.

Try it: change the price weight in the GPU market →

Terms used here

Capability
What a product can do for one job. Price is not part of it. Read the lesson
Grade (S–F)
A letter from S (excellent) to F for one job, such as 1440p gaming. Read the lesson
Value
How good the current price is under your priorities, from 0 to 100 within the view. Read the lesson
Priorities
How much price, performance, memory, power or warranty matter to you. Read the lesson